| | 1707 Feke, Robert | | 1848 Harnett, William Michael | | 1880 Dove, Arthur |
| | 1738 Copley, John Singleton | | 1848 Jones, Hugh Bolton | | 1880 Garber, Daniel |
| | 1755 Stuart, Gilbert | | 1849 Chase, William Merritt | | 1880 Hofmann, Hans |
| | 1779 Allston, Washington | | 1851 Anshutz, Thomas | | 1881 Gleizes, Albert |
| | 1793 Havell, Robert | | 1852 Robinson, Theodore | | 1881 Léger, Fernand |
| | 1796 Catlin, George | | 1853 Carlsen, Emil | | 1882 Bellows, George |
| | 1796 Durand, Asher | | 1853 Twachtman, John Henry | | 1882 Hopper, Edward |
| | 1801 Cole, Thomas | | 1855 Beaux, Cecilia | | 1884 Beckmann, Max |
| | 1804 Lane, Fitz Hugh | | 1856 Cox, Kenyon | | 1884 Kroll, Leon |
| | 1810 Miller, Alfred Jacob | | 1856 Sargent, John Singer | | 1886 Hibbard, Aldro |
| | 1811 Bingham, George Caleb | | 1857 Dow, Arthur | | 1887 Archipenko, Alexander |
| | 1816 Kensett, John Frederick | | 1858 De Camp, Joseph Rodefer | | 1887 Chagall, Marc |
| | 1816 Leutze, Emanuel | | 1858 Metcalf, Willard Leroy | | 1887 Duchamp, Marcel |
| | 1819 Heade, Martin Johnson | | 1858 Prendergast, Maurice | | 1887 O'Keeffe, Georgia |
| | 1820 Whittredge, Thomas Worthington | | 1859 Hassam, Childe | | 1888 Albers, Josef |
| | 1823 Bradford, William | | 1861 Bunker, Dennis Miller | | 1889 Benton, Thomas Hart |
| | 1823 Cropsey, Jasper | | 1862 Benson, Frank | | 1890 Man Ray |
| | 1823 Gifford, Sanford | | 1862 Tarbell, Edmund Charles | | 1891 Ernst, Max |
| | 1824 Hunt, William Morris | | 1865 DuMond, Frank | | 1892 Davis, Stuart |
| | 1824 Johnson, Eastman | | 1865 Henri, Robert | | 1893 Avery, Milton |
| | 1825 Inness, George | | 1866 Luks, George | | 1893 Burchfield, Charles |
| | 1826 Church, Frederic | | 1869 Redfield, Edward | | 1893 Grosz, George |
| | 1828 Hart, James McDougal | | 1870 Glackens, William | | 1896 Masson, André |
| | 1829 Moran, Edward | | 1870 Marin, John | | 1898 Calder, Alexander |
| | 1830 Bierstadt, Albert | | 1871 Feininger, Lyonel | | 1898 de Lempicka, Tamara |
| | 1831 Brown, John George | | 1871 Sloan, John | | 1898 Marsh, Reginald |
| | 1832 Colman, Samuel | | 1872 Hawthorne, Charles | | 1899 Tamayo, Rufino |
| | 1835 La Farge, John | | 1872 Mondrian, Piet | | 1923 Artschwager, Richard Ernst |
| | 1836 Homer, Winslow | | 1873 Lawson, Ernest | | 1930 Johns, Jasper |
| | 1837 Bricher, Alfred | | 1874 Frieseke, Frederick | | 1932 Botero, Fernando |
| | 1837 Moran, Thomas | | 1875 Carlson, John Fabian | | 1935 Dine, Jim |
| | 1844 Eakins, Thomas | | 1875 Dixon, Maynard | | 1944 Larraz, Julio |
| | 1847 Blakelock, Ralph | | 1876 Miller, Kenneth Hayes | | |
| | 1848 Duveneck, Frank | | 1877 Hartley, Marsden | | |
